III. GROUNDS FOR INITIATING THE PROCEDURE, Decision_act (EU) 2006/937

In forcesince 5 Jul 2005
(75)

In its decision to initiate proceedings, the Commission expressed doubts that the measures implemented by Poland involved aid, essentially for three reasons:

The Commission had reasons to believe that the restructuring of HCz did not pass the private creditor test. It appeared that some public creditors were writing off more debts in the course of restructuring than they would have if they had faced bankruptcy, given the possession of first-class sureties, at least in the case of public institutional creditors. In these circumstances the Commission was reluctant to accept the Polish argument that overall the restructuring plan would produce a better return for the state than liquidation. Moreover, the Commission was not sure whether the public institutional creditors' consent was obtained purely on the basis of the Act of 30 October 2002 and whether the Operator really would receive valuable assets.

In addition, the Commission was not sure how HSCz had continued production without working capital and whether it had received other financial aid.

Finally, the Commission had information in its file that HCz had received various financial aid measures between 1997 and 2002.