The Irish authorities have not attempted to argue that the Foreign Income scheme complies with the Guidelines on aid to employment(17) under which certain aid measures may be considered compatible with the common market by virtue of Article 87(3)(c). However, the Commission notes that to the extent that section 222 is aimed at the maintenance of employment, the measure does not grant aid to a firm to persuade it not to lay off its workers, with the subsidy being calculated on the basis of the number of employees at the time the aid is granted. To the extent that both section 222 and section 847 are aimed at job creation, neither provision provides that the amount of aid per worker must be justified, nor that it shall not represent too high a proportion of the firm's production costs. The Foreign Income scheme cannot therefore be regarded as falling within the scope of the Guidelines on aid to employment.
Legitimate expectations and recovery