Recital 44, Decision_act (EU) 2003/601

In forcesince 17 Feb 2003

At first sight, section 222 might appear to be an investment aid measure. However, nothing in the legislation or in the information provided by the Irish authorities demonstrates that the criteria for granting the tax relief satisfy the regional aid guidelines in force at the time(11). To the extent that these guidelines provide for aid to be granted for initial investment or job creation, the Commission notes that, according to Ireland, tax relief was granted in respect of, inter alia, working capital, start-up and operating losses, capital injections, upgrading of plant, machinery and software, and refurbishment of facilities. As the Commission has consistently ruled in previous decisions, none of these is normally considered to constitute initial investment or job creation for which State aid may be granted. Similarly, the Commission notes that section 222 provides for tax relief for the maintenance of employment as well as for its creation. This is borne out by information provided by Ireland on the practical application of section 222. Similarly, nothing in the legislation or in the information provided by the Irish authorities demonstrates that controls were in place to ensure compliance with other rules on State aid, notably aid to sensitive sectors, aid to companies in difficulty and cumulation of aid. In particular, the Commission notes that relief was given in respect of production and processing of goods featuring in Annex I to the EC Treaty and in respect of operations which, according to the Irish authorities, would otherwise have been unviable.