An initial report drawn up by the management consultancy Roland Berger in January 1996 at the request of the German Government is ultimately uninformative as regards the questions being looked at here. Germany commissioned the report two years prior to the merger in order to examine SBW's recovery strategy. Its purpose was not to assess corporate value or a price at which the company might be sold. The report identifies a positive "restructuring value" of SBW's holdings outside the coal industry. In a letter sent to the Commission in April 2000, however, Roland Berger explained that such value could on no account be regarded as the probable sales value of such holdings. Implementation of these restructuring measures - which were geared to SBW continuing on a stand-alone basis - never took place and, according to Roland Berger, could have been achieved only on the basis of substantial investment.
Recital 60, Decision_act (EU) 2003/36
In forcesince 7 May 2002