Recital 35, Decision_act (EU) 2003/36

In forcesince 7 May 2002

Taking imported coal separately, the parties succeeded in increasing their absolute sales of imported coal from [...]* million tonnes ([...]* million tonnes excluding SBW's imports) in 1994 to [...]* million tonnes in 2001. However, this increase in absolute quantities reflects the competitive position of the parties only to a limited extent, since it was associated with the rise in imported coal's share of the total market. The parties' share of the imported coal market did indeed go up from 1994 ([10 to 20 %]*, or [10 to 20 %]* excluding SBW's imports) to 1997 ([30 to 40 %]*, or [30 to 40 %]*, i.e. in the period preceding the merger. After the merger, however, as Table 3 shows, it remained stable with slight fluctuations between 1997 ([30 to 40 %]*, or [30 to 40 %]* and 2001 ([25 to 35 %]*, and latterly shows a downward trend. RAG, therefore, was unable to defend its slight increases in market share in 1999 and 2000. It should also be pointed out that RAG meets only a small portion of its imports into Germany from its own sources of production and must buy most of its imports from other producers. Thus it has no perceptible advantage as regards access to sources of supply compared with its competitors in the import field.

Table 3

Parties' share of the imported coal segment