Recital 52, Decision_act (EU) 2003/27

In forcesince 11 Jul 2001

Nonetheless, the CVE and the CCB do not rule out the possibility that, in the exercise of their tax autonomy, the Provincial Councils may adopt tax measures that are caught by Article 87(1) of the Treaty. However, in the present case, they take the view that the 45 % tax credit is not so caught, since it only meets the criterion of being granted from state resources. It does not distort competition, because its payment implies that the recipient company has made profits. Moreover, its amount cannot be determined in advance, since, for example, if there were no profits, the aid would not be paid and if the profits were insufficient, it would be less than 45 %. The same applies as regards the effect on trade. This should be established in each specific case: it is not sufficient that trade might be affected. For the rest, the CVE and the CCB examine whether there is any specificity deriving from the threshold of ESP 2500 million or the need to obtain the Provincial Council's approval in order to apply the tax credit. In this respect, they consider that the threshold does not involve specificity, since it is objective and non-discriminatory. As for the determination by the Provincial Council of (i) the investments qualifying for the 45 % tax credit; (ii) the deadlines and limitations applicable to the deduction; and (iii) the duration of the investment process, which may include investments made during the preparatory phase of the project giving rise to the investments, the CVE and the CCB take the view that this does not involve the exercise of a discretionary power, but is governed by rules and, ultimately, subject to judicial review.