The Rioja Regional Government states that the tax measures constitute State aid, since they satisfy all four criteria set out in Article 87 of the Treaty. In support of this contention, it argues in particular that the purpose and effect of the 45 % tax credit is to relieve the recipient of part of the tax burden which would otherwise have been imposed on its profits. It therefore constitutes a financial advantage for recipient firms, which, because there are no quid pro quos for the authorities, involves a loss of tax revenue. This means that the recipients' business benefits, as they have a competitive advantage over all other firms. In addition to the specificity of substance, in the form of a minimum investment of ESP 2500 million, the Rioja Regional Government states that the discretionary nature of the 45 % tax credit is due partly to the authorities' ability to determine firms eligible for aid, deadlines and maximum limits and partly to the fact that the granting of the tax credit is not automatic.
Recital 47, Decision_act (EU) 2003/27
In forcesince 11 Jul 2001