The CVE and the CCB consider that the tax system of each Basque province does not meet the specificity criterion in Article 87(1) of the Treaty merely because it applies only in part of a Member State. In support of this view, they argue that the Commission's usual practice of considering that there is specificity when a tax measure is applied to part of the Member State is appropriate where there is a single tax system. However, it is not relevant where there are various tax systems in the same Member State. The practice, furthermore, is contrary to the coherence of the Spanish tax system, which is multiple by nature. Each system is applied exclusively in one part of the territory. Thus, each one of the systems is not a regional system, but a unique system applicable to the territory concerned. Moreover, the losses of tax revenue which result from certain tax measures are not the subject of a transfer from the central government. On the contrary, they have to be offset, either by increasing the revenues from other taxes or by cutting public expenditure. In addition, the specific nature of the Spanish tax system should not be penalised through the application of Community law. For the rest, any distortions of competition resulting from the existence of five tax systems should be tackled through the Community rules on tax harmonisation.
Recital 51, Decision_act (EU) 2003/27
In forcesince 11 Jul 2001