C/G argues further that the Commission's allegation in the Statement of Objections that certain executives were aware of the existence of the cartel is not supported by any facts (C/G Reply to the Statement of Objections, p. 2).
In this context the Commission states that as early as 22 July 1992, - two months after the "Top Guy" meeting in London - the weekly report to the Chairman observed (Appendix 25): "(We) have effectively booked 'our share' in Germany for the second half. All at DM 4000 +/MT."
The reference by C/G to "our share" is strongly indicative that some understanding already existed that its sales should be restricted in the particular market. Certainly VAW Carbon seems to have had the impression (Appendix 26) that C/G had agreed to limit its sales in Germany. Despite C/G's professed ignorance as to why VAW Carbon could have gained this impression (Article 11 reply, p. 7), such an understanding would be entirely consistent with SGL's repeated insistence that C/G had sold "too much" in Europe.
C/G employees also knew of the "unwritten promise" among the world graphite producers not to increase their capacity as decided in London in May 1992 (Appendix 27).
Indeed its agents in Brussels even referred openly to one major customer in France awarding its business to C/G instead of SGL: "We benefited of a negative action against one of the Biggies - SGL. They [meaning the customer in question] hope to destabilise the cartel in making one party very unhappy." (Appendix 28).