Recital 35, Decision_act (EU) 2002/271

In forcesince 18 Jul 2001

In December 1997 the Commission addressed requests for information under Article 11 of Regulation No 17 to some 67 consumers of graphite electrodes, asking them to provide detailed information on suppliers, pricing and discounts.

A first set of requests under Article 11 was sent to SGL, VAW Carbon and Conradty between June 1997 and July 1998, requiring detailed explanations concerning contacts with competitors, SGL's warnings of the forthcoming investigation and travel expense records for certain employees.

In December 1997 requests under Article 11 (in general terms) were addressed to the Japanese producers SDK, SEC, Tokai and Nippon, which were not at the time suspected of direct involvement in the agreements. In their replies the last three named companies claimed that they set their prices in Europe according to "market information" and in negotiations with customers. Further requests for information were sent to them in April and May 1998 regarding their presence at meetings.

On the basis of information received during 1998 and early 1999, a further set of Article 11 requests was addressed by the Commission to SGL, VAW Carbon and Conradty in March 1999 and to C/G on 8 June 1999.