Recital 39, Decision_act (EU) 2002/271

In forcesince 18 Jul 2001

SGL argues that it did not have complete access to the file as the Commission refused to disclose to SGL its internal documents. SGL maintains further that the Commission did not provide it with a list and description of its internal documents; it was therefore not possible for SGL to get a complete overview of contacts between the Commission and other companies in the context of their cooperation (SGL's letter of 9 March 2000, SGL's reply to the Statement of Objections, p. 23).

This argument must be rejected. According to well established case-law (see the judgments of the Court of First Instance in Case T-7/89 Hercules v Commission [1991] ECR II-1711, paragraph 54 and Joined Cases T-25/95 etc. Cimenteries CBR and others v Commission, not yet reported, paragraph 420), the Commission is under no obligation with regard to the rights of the defence to grant access to its internal documents during the procedure. A list and a description of internal documents, as requested by SGL, would thus not contribute to the exercise of the undertaking's right of defence.

As far as contacts with undertakings in the context of their cooperation are concerned, the Commission considers that SGL's reasoning is based on a fundamentally wrong premise. Those contacts with other companies are in fact not part of the internal file. The documents are kept in the normal investigation file to which the parties had access; several documents however were treated, at the request of the companies concerned, as confidential.

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (First Chamber) of 17 December 1991. SA Hercules Chemicals NV v Commission of the European CommunitiDecision

    17 Dec 1991 · 61989TJ0007

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Fourth Chamber, extended composition) of 15 March 2000. Cimenteries CBR and Others v Commission of Decision

    15 Mar 2000 · 61995TJ0025