The main evidential significance of this table (which did not, at face value, indicate any collusion between the producers and could be explained as a purely internal document) derives from the fact that virtually identical tables were in the possession of other producers and have now been supplied to the Commission.
An almost identical version of the table (reference 13-6-95/GV) was obtained by the Commission from SDK on 13 March 1998 [...]*. A later version dated 2 August 1995 was faxed to SDK by SGL on 23 August (Appendix 7).
Exactly the same table as had been sent to SDK on 23 August was faxed by SGL to UCAR's Chairman on 25 August 1995 (Appendix 8).
On 24 October 1995, the same document was faxed to Carbide/Graphite Group by its German sales agent who had received it by fax from VAW Carbon (Appendix 9; C/G's Article 11 reply of 22 July 1999, p. 6).
Similar price tables found during the investigation at SGL are annexed as Appendices 10 to 14.
These spreadsheets were clearly part of the exercise of fixing prices for the European markets and may be taken as typical of the documentation produced and used by the cartel during the whole of its operation.