Recital 178, Decision_act (EU) 2002/271

In forcesince 18 Jul 2001

SGL claimed variously (and not entirely consistently) that:

(a)

under the general ne bis in idem principle of criminal law, it should not be prosecuted or sanctioned a second time for the same action under EC competition law, the conviction and the fine in the United States having already expunged the totality of its culpability;

(b)

the United States had fined SGL on the basis of total world turnover;

(c)

on the basis of general principles of justice and equity, the Commission in calculating any fine should "set off" against the appropriate amount the fine imposed in the United States and any punitive element in the civil damage awards.

–

Arguments of the Commission