The question of the appropriate addressee arises only in one case, where the attribution of the conduct of the subsidiary to its parent company must be discussed. That case is VAW Carbon.
The original VAW Carbon GmbH (registered in Grevenbroich) acted until 31 December 1995 as a "mere selling company" (reine Vertriebsgesellschaft) for the carbon and graphite products manufactured by VAW Aluminium AG. According to VAW Carbon's reply of 9 July 1999 to the Commission's request for information of 28 June 1999 (point 2) it was a wholly owned subsidiary of VAW Aluminium AG.
VAW Aluminium AG is a large industrial group with diverse activities and a network of subsidiaries. Its carbon (and graphite electrode) sector was the subject of corporate restructuring on two occasions during the period of the cartel.