Although it is apparent from the statements of both SDK and UCAR that contacts between UCAR, Sigri and the Japanese producers had started as early as 1991, the Commission will in the present case limit its assessment under the competition rules and the application of any fines to the period from May 1992, this being the date of the first "Top Guy" meeting in London when the basic principles for the cartellisation of the market were agreed.
It should of course be noted that in so far as the cartel covered Austria, Finland, Norway and Sweden, this does not constitute an infringement of the competition rules prior to 1 January 1994, when the EEA Agreement came into effect.
The participation in the infringement of UCAR, SGL and the Japanese producers from 21 May 1992 is established by the participation in the first "Top Guy" meeting of their respective Presidents/General Managers or (in the case of Nippon and SEC) another undertaking representing their interests.
In any event, the fact that Nippon and SEC did not attend the first "Top Guy" meeting of 21 May 1992 is immaterial since they were both represented by Tokai and were themselves present at the first "Working Level" meeting only four days later, as was VAW Carbon.
The involvement of C/G in the collusion will be taken from January 1993 when collusion on pricing was openly discussed for the first time (see point 81 above).