Recital 111, Decision_act (EU) 2002/271

In forcesince 18 Jul 2001

The continuing agreement between the producers had an appreciable effect on trade between Member States and between EEA contracting parties.

Article 81(1) of the Treaty is aimed at agreements which might harm the attainment of a single market between the Member States, whether by partitioning national markets or by affecting the structure of competition within the common market. Similarly, Article 53(1) of the EEA Agreement is directed at agreements that undermine the achievement of a homogeneous European Economic Area.

As demonstrated in the "Interstate trade" section (see point 19 above), the graphite electrode market is characterised by a substantial volume of trade between Member States. There is also a considerable volume of trade between the Community and EFTA: Norway imports 100 % of its requirements, primarily from SGL, UCAR and VAW Carbon, and prior to the accession of Austria, Finland and Sweden, Austria imported a substantial quantity and the other two countries the totality of their graphite electrode requirements.

The application of Articles 81(1) of the Treaty and 53(1) of the EEA Agreementto a cartel is not, however, limited to that part of the members' sales that actually involve the transfer of goods from one State to another. Nor is it necessary, in order for these provisions to apply, to show that the individual conduct of each participant, as opposed to the cartel as a whole, affected trade between Member States (see the judgment of the Court of First Instance in Case T-13/89 Imperial Chemical Industries v Commission [1992] ECR II-1021, at paragraph 304).

In the present case, the cartel arrangements covered virtually all trade throughout the Community and EEA in this important industrial sector. The withdrawal from particular markets of the "non-home market" producers as well as the existence of a price-fixing and quota mechanism must have resulted, or was likely to result, in the automatic diversion of trade patterns from the course they would otherwise have followed (see the judgment of the Court of Justice in Joined Cases 209 to 215 and 218/78 Van Landewyck and others v Commission [1980] ECR 3125, at paragraph 170).

In so far as the activities of the cartel related to sales in countries that are not members of the Community or the EEA, they lie outside the scope of this Decision.

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (First Chamber) of 10 March 1992. Imperial Chemical Industries plc v Commission of the European CommDecision

    10 Mar 1992 · 61989TJ0013

  • Treaty establishing the European Community81Law

  • celex=31913D0089