There is evidence that the collusion between the producers of graphite electrodes affecting the Community began with contacts as early as 1990 and developed during late 1991 and the early part of 1992.
It is not necessary, in order for there to be an infringement of Article 81(1) of the Treaty, for the participants to have agreed in advance upon a comprehensive common plan. The concept of "agreement" in Article 81(1) of the Treaty would apply to the inchoate understandings and partial and conditional agreements in the bargaining process which lead up to the definitive agreement. Further, the process of negotiation and preparation culminating in the adoption of an overall plan to regulate the market may well also (depending on the circumstances) be correctly characterised as a concerted practice.
For the purposes of the present case, however, the Commission will begin its assessment with the definitive adoption and implementation by the producers of the common cartel plan.