As a derogation from the general prohibition on State aid contained in Article 87(1) of the Treaty, Article 87(2)(b) must be interpreted restrictively. Adverse climatic events such as hail, frost, ice, drought, rain and wind do not of themselves constitute natural disasters within the meaning of Article 87(2)(b). However, it has been constant Commission practice in the agricultural sector, in accordance with the principles set out in Commission Working Paper VI/5934/86, to which the Italian authorities refer in their comments, to treat adverse climatic events of this type as natural disasters once the losses suffered by the beneficiary reach a certain rate. Thus the Commission has permitted aid to be paid under Article 87(2)(b) of the Treaty to compensate for losses caused by adverse climatic conditions such as hail, frost, ice, drought, rain and wind, provided that the losses suffered by the beneficiaries amount in normal regions to 30 % (and in less-favoured areas 20 %) of normal annual production, defined as the average production of the three years preceding that in which the damage occurred. Where productivity of capital stock is lost, the loss must exceed 10 % in the first year and the total loss, spread over several years, must exceed 30 % or 20 % of a normal year's production. The aid must not exceed the individual farmer's losses. This practice has recently been confirmed in the Community Guidelines for State aid in the agriculture sector(8).
Recital 31, Decision_act (EU) 2001/95
In forcesince 20 Sep 2000