Neither Article 87(2)(b) of the Treaty nor the Commission's practice to date provides for time limits on the payment of aid to compensate for damage caused by exceptional climatic events. The Italian authorities consider that any such limit should be set beforehand so as to put all the Member States on the same footing and to ensure legal certainty for all. Furthermore, the concept of a "reasonable period" proposed by the Commission is subjective: it does not provide any legal certainty, may result in unequal treatment and entails a real risk that the Member States will act in different ways. This is shown by the fact that in the part of the same letter dealing with compensation for plant diseases, the Commission describes the period between the occurrence of the damage and the payment of the aid as "not unreasonable". The damage occurred in 1994/1995, 1995/1996 and 1996/1997. A measure concerning events that occurred from 1994 onwards is thus regarded by the Commission as "reasonable". Naturally the Italian authorities agree with the Commission's assessment of the compensation for damage caused by tomato yellow leaf curl. However, in all logic and also for the sake of equality of treatment, the Sardinia Region would have expected the supplementary aid granted for disasters occurring from 1994 to be declared compatible.
Recital 13, Decision_act (EU) 2001/95
In forcesince 20 Sep 2000