The Commission informed the Netherlands by letter dated 13 July 1998 that it was initiating proceedings because it had doubts as to whether the aid complied with the conditions laid down in the Community Guidelines on State aid for environmental protection(4). The doubts related to the determination of the amount of the extra investment costs. The Community Guidelines stipulate that the eligible costs must be strictly confined to the extra investment costs necessary to meet environmental objectives (point 3.2.1). The following are briefly the points at issue:
The replacement costs. It is the Commission's usual practice to calculate the extra investment costs by comparing the new, environmentally friendly investment with the costs of setting up similar production capacity using conventional technologies.
The Commission was unable to determine the extra investment costs on the basis of the information received, since information on the replacement costs was lacking. The Commission believes that the preservation of the old unit does not dispense the Netherlands authorities from the obligation of comparing the planned investment with the overall costs of a conventional unit calculated at current prices.
The 70 MW increase in electricity generation. It is stated in the notification that the project will result in an increase in electricity capacity. Total capacity for the Netherlands will be increased by some 0,3 %. When the proceedings were initiated, it was not clear to the Commission how this was taken into account in calculating the eligible costs.