Recital 30, Decision_act (EU) 1999/199

In forcesince 10 Feb 1999

As regards the second justification, the Portuguese authorities did not refer to any specific economies of scale, stating instead that the airport needed to promote greater utilisation of its facilities. In its Decision 95/364/EC (14), the Commission responded to the economies of scale argument thus: 'the Commission considers that such a system could be justified solely by economies of scale achieved by the airways authority. This does not apply in the case at issue. The airways authority has not demonstrated to the Commission that handling the take-off or landing of an aircraft belonging to one airline rather than to another gives rise to economies of scale. The handling of the landing or take-off of an aircraft requires the same service, irrespective of its owner or the number of aircraft belonging to a given airline. The airways authority might, at most, argue that economies of scale occur at the level of invoicing since a single invoice covering a large number of movements can be issued to a carrier with a high level of traffic whilst many invoices covering only a few movements are needed for other carriers. Such economies of scale are, however, negligible`. The same reasoning applies in the case in hand, since the handling of landing and take-off requires the same service, irrespective of the number of aircraft belonging to a given airline.