However, those reductions in production and workforce have not produced the planned reduction in operating losses, owing to the unfavourable productivity trend and the changes which had to be made to operating methods in response to the accidents in 1995.
Beyond those changes, both undertakings have taken measures contrary to the goal of a progressive and continuous reduction in activity as laid down in Article 4 of Decision No 3632/93/ECSC if undertakings are to qualify for aid for the reduction of activity.
Hunosa and Minas de Figaredo SA have subcontracted operations with a view to restoring some of the activity lost with the departure of their permanent staff. They have made heavier infrastructure investment than announced with a view to continuing activities having no prospect of economic viability. In its letter dated 23 May 1997 Spain announced that the closure plan proposed for Hunosa installations in the 1994-97 phase would be extended beyond the approved deadlines.
Moreover, Hunosa has reopened installations closed down by Minas de Lieres SA as part of the 1991-93 restructuring plan - closures for which aid was authorised. Production at those installations led to operating losses of ESP 487 million in 1994, ESP 791 million in 1995 and ESP 1 016 million in 1996. The Commission cannot approve aid to cover these operating losses.
By letter dated 20 February 1998 in reply to the request from the Commission under Article 9(6) of Decision No 3632/93/ECSC, Spain informed the Commission that it was prepared to abide by the broad objectives of the 1994-97 phase of the activity reduction plans approved by the Commission in Decision 94/1072/ECSC and, consequently, that it would proceed, before Decision No 3632/93/ECSC expired, to correct the measures contrary to the objective of reducing activity.