In its Decision 80/257/ECSC (51), the Commission specified how calculation models could amount to recommendations:
'They encourage the user companies to work from the figures contained in the model, or at least to keep close to them, when calculating their costs and thus indirectly when setting their selling prices. To this extent it is immaterial whether the cost components are expressed in straight figures or in the form of percentage surcharges. Either way, what may once have been offered as a service to explain to companies the various ways of achieving cost-related price formation has become a means of exerting a real, powerful influence on their pricing policy.`
The undertakings must therefore have been aware of the Commission's position on the adoption of a single method of calculation for the alloy surcharge.
Several undertakings invoke the principle of market transparency laid down in Article 60 of the ECSC Treaty