It seems that the general application of the method in force in 1994 dates back to 1988 (with the exception of the trigger values). In its abovementioned Decision 90/417/ECSC of 18 July 1990, the Commission found against an agreement and concerted practices between parties which related in particular to prices. The agreement had been in force at least between May 1986 and October 1988. The decision was not contested. The Commission does not, however, have sufficient evidence that the adoption of an identical calculation method was the result of concerted action as such. That is why the original adoption of the method is not the subject of this Decision. However, the circumstances in which the surcharge trigger value was recently amended points to the existence, at least in the present case, of collusion in the setting of the value and the date of implementation.
Some producers (47) claim that customers are in favour of the surcharge method