, Decision_act (EU) 1997/14

In forcesince 17 Jul 1996
–

monitoring by the Commission together with annual reports.

VIII

When initiating the procedure, the Commission stated that at this stage all that was required of the French authorities was to demonstrate that the aid formed an essential part of a complete restructuring plan designed to restore viability. Although staff had been cut, it was not clear that a coordinated strategy has been developed to restore viability. Generally the aid had been granted in response to the awkward financial position in which the company found itself rather than as a tool for developing and improving economic performance. In fact, it seemed that the aid had protected CGM from market forces.

The company's problems derived mainly from management decisions, like the new strategy adopted in 1989, the serious overcapacity on certain routes (particularly services to North America and the Far East where CGM was making heavy losses) and the weakness of the dollar. This resulted in higher levels of debt (which levelled out at FF 2 500 million in 1990 and then rose to FF 5 million at the end of 1992) that could not be wiped out by operating revenue.

The plans for restructuring CGM prepared by the French authorities identified areas where costs could be reduced, envisaging the gradual withdrawal of the company from loss-making activities and the gradual sale of its assets and reductions in staff and capacity. The aim of the national authorities is to privatize the company in the autumn since they considered that market conditions are currently favourable. In view of the number of declarations of interest, this assessment is probably correct.

The alternative to State support leading to the restructuring of CGM would have been the liquidation of the company. However, for political reasons, the French authorities did not consider this option.

IX

The common interest of the Community

The main question concerning aid to CGM is whether granting this aid is in the common interest. In shipping, the common interest would be served by measures designed to keep vessels flying a Community flag and to employ as high a proportion of Community seafarers as possible on board these vessels. To date, the subsidies have allowed CGM to continue to operate vessels under the French flag and to continue to employ Community seafarers.

In addition, the restructuring aid must satisfy a number of conditions:

(i)

Restoration of long-term viability