The whole investment made by the State in the restructuring of Iritecna will not produce any appropriate return in the future. The injections made over the years 1991 to 1993, before the company was put into liquidation, were clearly carried out with the purpose of putting into effect the first and most urgent restructuring measures. These funds were used simply to cover the liquidation and restructuring losses of some of the subsidiaries of Iritecna, without any prospect of any return. Given the poor performance of Iritecna over the whole period, they have to be regarded as part of a process which has led to the shareholder's decision to liquidate Iritecna and to completely divest itself of the business. No private shareholder would have accepted such poor performance for such a long period. He would have liquidated or thoroughly restructured much earlier. They are therefore to be considered as aid.
The losses attributed to the liquidation process are, by their very nature, aid. They are liabilities that are being guaranteed and finally paid by the shareholder under Article 2362 of the Italian Civil Code, following the placing of the company in voluntary liquidation. Such a guarantee has existed since Iritecna was created in 1991, while the company has continued to be heavily loss-making over this period. Under these conditions a private investor would have tried to limit his commitments with regard to the subsidiary, by deciding to put it into liquidation from the moment it could not reasonably expect a restoration of its financial viability and at a moment where its assets/liabilities position still showed a surplus. As IRI did not exhibit such rational behaviour and only decided to voluntarily liquidate Iritecna much later, in order to write off losses and debts and thereby to help the relaunching of its activities in Fintecna, the cost of such operation must be considered as aid. This cost, amounting to Lit 3 400 billion, includes by deduction the expected income of IRI from the sale of Fintecna.
In light of the above and given the characteristics of the company and of the sector in which it is operating, the Commission concludes that the global amount of Lit 4 490 billion does distort intra-Community trade, and therefore constitutes State aid within the meaning of Article 92 (1) of the Treaty and Article 61 (1) of the EEA Agreement.