, Decision_act (EU) 1995/524

In forcesince 7 Jun 1995

According to this principle, which has been largely confirmed by the Court's case-law and by the practice of the Commission, aid is involved in a transaction if this would not have been undertaken by a private investor operating under normal market economy conditions.

On the basis of the information provided to the Commission and as stated above, the amount invested by the Italian State in the restructuring of Iritecna - through is holding company IRI - amounts to Lit 4 490 billion.

The different injections, partly already effected, are summarized in the following table:

>TABLE>

As regards the Italian authorities' argument that IRI's internal funds only have been employed without any direct injection by the State, the Commission observes that IRI is an industrial holding company which is 100 % owned by the Italian Treasury. Therefore, any decision by IRI to invest in its subsidiaries and any subsequent lack of return on such investment produces a corresponding negative effect on the return that IRI should provide to its shareholder. Even if no capital injection was made into IRI for the purpose of Iritecna's restructuring, the restructuring costs have been financed with proceeds which otherwise would have reduced the global loss of IRI group, or would have benefited its shareholder, the State, through dividends or increased capital value. In fact, IRI has not provided any return to its shareholder in the last decade; the funds it has made available to its subsidiaries are therefore to be considered State resources. Moreover, IRI could not have chosen to continuously recapitalize Iritecna, despite its continuously deteriorating performance and accounts, without the tacit or explicit approval of the public shareholder.