3.5. Such a procedure was applied in the case of the 18 studies relating to conservation of European cities and funded under budget heading B2-6023 of the 1992 budget, with an appropriation of ECU 1,5 million. A fortiori, such a procedure should also be implemented in the case of pilot projects, the cost of which is 60 times higher.
The innovative nature of projects
3.6. The experimental or innovative nature of projects subsidized has still, in most cases, to be demonstrated. Actions similar to those funded as pilot projects can mostly be found in operational programmes covering Objectives 1 and 2, classed as, for example, aid for tourism, the improvement of run-down areas, environmental action or the renovation of historic centres. Even when a pilot project includes some more innovative aspect, this aspect is often difficult to put into action and, as the Court observed during its on-the-spot checks, remains only partially implemented, if at all.
3.7. In some cases (e.g. Bordeaux, Copenhagen, London, Lyons and Rotterdam), funding under Article 10 has made it possible to grant aid to municipalities which at that time would not otherwise have been eligible for any ERDF action. The project reports and information obtained on site by the Court with respect to the Fuenlabrada and Parla project in Spain showed that these municipalities had been chosen by the national authorities because they were the only large units south of Madrid that were not included in the areas eligible under Objective 2.
The state of progress of the projects examined
3.8. The aim of the Fuenlabrada and Parla project mentioned above is to improve the area around an industrial zone and create a kind of 'green belt`. The area in question is partly agricultural land and partly waste ground which is subject to illegal dumping of waste. Strictly speaking, the project hardly qualifies as 'urban`. The execution period originally stated ran from April 1991 to September 1993. At the end of 1993, work had still not begun because of problems concerning the availability of land and compulsory purchase procedures - questions that had not been settled prior to approval of the project. The deadline for completion of the work was extended to September 1994, though there was no guarantee that this second deadline could be met. At the end of 1993, the 50 % advance of ECU 2,3 million, which had been paid by the Commission in early 1992, remained available in the accounts of the autonomous region of Madrid.