3.1. Under Article 10 of Council Regulation (EC) No 4254/88 of 19 December 1988 (), the ERDF may (chapter B2-18 of the budget for 'Temporary measures and innovative actions`) contribute to the funding, at Community level, of pilot projects that:
promote the creation of infrastructures, investment in enterprises and other specific measures with a marked Community value, particularly in internal and external border areas of the Community;
encourage exchanges of experience and development cooperation among the Community`s regions, as well as innovative actions.
3.2. Although it mainly relates to economic and social cohesion, expenditure under this Article 10 is closely linked to the issue of the urban environment, since, during the budget years 1990-1993, a total of 32 urban pilot projects, with execution periods varying between a year and a half and four and a half years, were funded, for an overall investment of ECU 204,3 million and Community aid of ECU 101,1 million. Selection of these projects was based on the following criteria: urban planning or renewal of European interest, innovative nature, demonstration potential, contribution to the development of the region concerned. The Court examined seven of these 32 projects.
3.3. The projects subsidized, which are listed in Table 2, cover four main areas of intervention: economic development in areas with social problems, environmental actions linked to economic ends, the revitalization of historic centres, and the utilization of technological advantages in towns and cities. Actions generally comprise the restoration of buildings, as well as exchanges of experience, training activities, study centres or service centres.
Selection of initiatives
3.4. Pilot projects and, therefore, the towns or cities to benefit from aid, were selected on the basis of bilateral mutual agreements, subject, moreover, to few formalities. The conditions for the granting of public aid seem to lack transparency and the methods applied do not make it possible, in particular, to ascertain whether the initiatives selected were in fact the most worthy. At the very least, the procedure for the granting of aid should include a simple but specific public call for tenders to ensure that potential initiatives can be identified, and it should also include the drawing-up of a set of criteria for assessment and comparison that make it possible to classify such initiatives in order of merit.