Recital 93, Decision_act (EU) 1994/601

In forcesince 13 Jul 1994

For France, as two price tables found at Cascades show, detailed discussions took place in which the three main suppliers, namely Aussedat-Rey (De Lancey), Béghin and Cascades agreed the prices to be charged to some 80 customers on the occasion of the two planned price increases in 1988. The documents set out the 'prix planchers définis après hausse' (defined floor prices after the increase) for UC, GC 1 and GC 2 and compare the old price with the new prices which each customer is to pay after the increase comes into force.

Another document found at Cascades - and clearly connected with the same exercise - shows the tonnage supplied by producers referred to as 'A', 'B' and 'C' to each customer in France during 1987 together with the floor price to be applied to each customer from 1 March 1988 for UC, GC 1 and GC 2 grades. (A is 'Aussedet-Rey', i.e. De Lancey; B is 'Béghin' and C 'Cascades'.)

Cascades admits that the three French producers met in Paris on 19 January and 10 May 1988, 'afin d'analyser le marché français du carton' (in order to analyse the French cartonboard market) (Article 11 reply of 19 August 1991).

Given the context and timing, the exercise must have been part of the general plan to increase the price level for cartonboard in two stages during 1988. It involves the detailed working out on a customer-by-customer basis in France of the pricing targets set in the JMC (see recital 77).

The Commission officials also discovered at Cascades tables showing the major customers of Cascades in France together with the tonnage supplied to each of them by different producers during various periods or months in 1988 compared with the result of the previous year.

The producers named in these tables are Cascades, CBC (Stora), De Lancey, Feldmuehle (Stora), FS-Karton (M-M), KNP, TBM (MoDo), Kopparfors (Stora), Finnboard, Djupafors and Duffel (the last two both now Cascades).

(d)

United Kingdom