Recital 110, Decision_act (EU) 1994/601

In forcesince 13 Jul 1994

Besides contesting the factual evidence on which the statement of objections was based, several of the producers sought to rely on an economic analysis of the cartonboard industry which was commissioned for the purposes of this procedure from a firm of consultants. Nine of the producers (including Sarrió, which later effectively dissociated itself from its findings) had subscribed to the survey, which concluded inter alia that

–

price changes in the industry were explained by changes in unit costs and demand,

–

only a loose correlation existed between announced price increases and movements in actual prices paid by individual customers.

In the opinion of the author of this study, the price announcements reflected an 'aspiration' or intention by the manufacturer to increase prices which in practice might well not be realized.

Tables were produced comparing price data for some 113 customers with the price initiatives identified by the Commission; although there were differences between the GC and GD market segments, the average mean achieved price in ecu and in national currencies was always below the list price.

The producers involved argued that the study supported their contention that whatever might have been discussed in meetings (and several of them contested the Commission's assessment of the evidence on this point; see recitals 108 and 109) there was no effect upon real price levels which were determined by the free play of natural market forces.

2.

The Commission's assessment