As can be seen from their internal pricing documentation, the producers not only announced the agreed price increases but also with few exceptions took firm steps to ensure that they were imposed on the customers. For the most part the price initiatives were judged a success. If the first price rise of 1988 did not bring average net prices up by the amounts notified, it did turn round the fall in prices and eliminated very low prices and extreme price differentials.
During 1989 and 1990 the declared objective of increasing actual price levels by 15 % was achieved.
On many occasions and at many accounts the producers succeeded in making the customer pay the whole amount of the increase. This does not of course mean that the average net realization per tonne of each producer went up immediately by the full amount of the announced price rise.
It is true that in principle the price increase was normally announced as a flat rate increase (e.g. DM 15 per 100 kg) applicable to all customers whatever the actual price they might be paying. However, the pricing structure for cartonboard is complex and an increase of a particular amount to the basic price (for 10 or 15 tonne lots) might in fact involve a somewhat lesser increase on the final net price once account is taken of discounts and rebates.
Further, the practice of giving several months' notice of an increase (so that customers could in their turn pass on the price rise to end users) might equally prompt them to try to negotiate the size of the announced price increase with the producers before it became effective, although (a) the virtually simultaneous announcement of the same increase by all the producers across the whole of western Europe acted as a brake upon the ability of their customers to play one potential supplier off against another, and (b) the publicity given by the producers to the equilibrium between supply and demand from 1988 onward underlined to customers their common resolve to implement the increases.
Even if all the producers stayed resolute on introducing the full increase, the possibilities fur customers of switching to a cheaper quality or grade meant that a supplying producer might have to make some concessions to its traditional customers as regards timing or give additional incentives in the form of tonnage rebates or large order discounts in order for the customer to accept the full basic-price increase. A price increase would therefore inevitably take some time before it worked through.