Recital 8, Decision_act (EU) 1992/35

In forcesince 11 Jun 1991

The Community market for horserace betting and related services

The provision of trade statistics for service activities is generally difficult. For the service activity concerned by this case, namely horserace betting and related services, it is particularly difficult. Nevertheless the information provided below is sufficient in the Commission's opinion to demonstrate that there is trade and competition in horserace betting and related services, that the PMU and a limited number of competitors take part in this trade, that trade is increasing and that bookkeeping or tote betting cannot be considered as separate, unrelated markets whose development and functioning is independent each of the other. By these means the Commission considers that, notwithstanding the difficulty of obtaining precise trade statistics, the circumstances necessary to motivate its decision as laid down by the Court in its ruling in joined cases 296/82 and 318/82 (Leeuwarder) (1), have been satisfied.

Market composition, competition and trade

Horserace betting is allowed and operated in all Member States except Luxembourg. Even in Luxembourg permission was granted to a bookmaking multinational to open an 'agence hippique', although the venture did not subsequently materialize.

Betting can take two forms: bookmaking, where bets are placed against the bookmaker who thus can incur a financial risk dependent upon the precise bets placed and horserace result, or under a tote or totalizator arrangement, where bets are pooled and winnings paid out as a given percentage of the betting monies received with no financial risk to the operator of the betting system. A skilled bookmaker by adjusting the odds he provides on bets can much reduce and even eliminate totally his inherent financial risk.

The tote is the more common form of betting and is allowed and operated in the eleven Member States mentioned. Bookmaking is additionally allowed and operated in Belgium, Germany, Ireland, Italy and the United Kingdom.

The total estimated size of horserace betting in 1989 was ECU 14 570 million. The two largest national markets are the United Kingdom and France with totals of ECU 8 042 million and ECU 4 456 million respectively. The third largest national market is Germany (ECU 516 million) followed by Italy (ECU 444 million), Ireland (ECU 407 million) and Belgium (ECU 381 million). In the United Kingdom bookmaking is the dominant form representing over 96 % of all betting. In France only the tote form is allowed, so that by definition tote betting represents 100 % of all betting.

Ladbroke

In the United Kingdom the major market players are Ladbroke, Brent-Walker and Corals with market shares of approximately 25, 20 and 12 % respectively. All are organized as corporate bodies paying the normal company taxes in addition to the special separate taxes on betting which is a common feature in the Member States. In terms of trade, Ladbroke is the most active. It has offices in Ireland, Belgium, Germany, Italy, Spain and the Netherlands.

In Ireland Ladbroke has 50 betting shops and in Belgium it has over 900 outlets and is the market leader with an estimated market share of over 41 %. In second place is the PMU belge with a market share of approximately 16 %, an organization separate from the PMU (France), but operating on the same principle of tote betting. In third place is Tiercé franco-belge which is owned by Corals, with a 13 % market share. It is clear that both Ladbroke and Corals trade in the Belgian market.

In the Netherlands, Ladbroke currently operates the State monopoly on tote betting which was awarded after adjudication to Ladbroke by the Dutch authorities in 1986. At the end of 1990, Ladbroke sought to renegotiate the contract with the competent Dutch authorities, the NDR. During the course of these negotiations a number of Ladbroke units were visited by representatives of the NDR accompanied by representatives of the PMU. On 28 March 1991 Ladbroke gave six months notice of its intention to terminate the contract. Subsequently both Ladbroke and the PMU as well as certain other companies were asked to make proposals for the provision of a computer/totalizator system. On 25 May 1991 the competent Dutch authorities (NDR) published a press statement that they would purchase an American totalizator system. It is clear that Ladbroke is currently trading in the Dutch market and that the PMU and Ladbroke have been in competition in that market.

  • Judgment of the Court of 13 March 1985. Kingdom of the Netherlands and Leeuwarder Papierwarenfabriek BV v Commission of the European CommuniDecision

    13 Mar 1985 · 61982CJ0296

  • Judgment of the Court of 21 March 1990. Kingdom of Belgium v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    21 Mar 1990 · 61987CJ0142

  • case:eu=318/32