Art. 2d Directive (EU) 1989/665

Ineffectiveness

In forcesince 17 Apr 2014cited 44×
1.

Member States shall ensure that a contract is considered ineffective by a review body independent of the contracting authority or that its ineffectiveness is the result of a decision of such a review body in any of the following cases:

(a)

if the contracting authority has awarded a contract without prior publication of a contract notice in the Official Journal of the European Union without this being permissible in accordance with Directive 2014/24/EU or Directive 2014/23/EU;

(b)

in case of an infringement of Article 1(5), Article 2(3) or Article 2a(2) of this Directive, if this infringement has deprived the tenderer applying for review of the possibility to pursue pre-contractual remedies where such an infringement is combined with an infringement of Directive 2014/24/EU or Directive 2014/23/EU, if that infringement has affected the chances of the tenderer applying for a review to obtain the contract;

(c)

in the cases referred to in the second subparagraph of Article 2b(c) of this Directive, if Member States have invoked the derogation from the standstill period for contracts based on a framework agreement and a dynamic purchasing system.

2.

The consequences of a contract being considered ineffective shall be provided for by national law.

National law may provide for the retroactive cancellation of all contractual obligations or limit the scope of the cancellation to those obligations which still have to be performed. In the latter case, Member States shall provide for the application of other penalties within the meaning of Article 2e(2).

3.

Member States may provide that the review body independent of the contracting authority may not consider a contract ineffective, even though it has been awarded illegally on the grounds mentioned in paragraph 1, if the review body finds, after having examined all relevant aspects, that overriding reasons relating to a general interest require that the effects of the contract should be maintained. In this case, Member States shall provide for alternative penalties within the meaning of Article 2e(2), which shall be applied instead.

Economic interests in the effectiveness of the contract may only be considered as overriding reasons if in exceptional circumstances ineffectiveness would lead to disproportionate consequences.

However, economic interests directly linked to the contract concerned shall not constitute overriding reasons relating to a general interest. Economic interests directly linked to the contract include, inter alia, the costs resulting from the delay in the execution of the contract, the costs resulting from the launching of a new procurement procedure, the costs resulting from the change of the economic operator performing the contract and the costs of legal obligations resulting from the ineffectiveness.

4.

The Member States shall provide that paragraph 1(a) of this Article does not apply where:

the contracting authority considers that the award of a contract without prior publication of a contract notice in the Official Journal of the European Union is permissible in accordance with Directive 2014/24/EU or Directive 2014/23/EU,

the contracting authority has published in the Official Journal of the European Union a notice as described in Article 3a of this Directive expressing its intention to conclude the contract, and,

the contract has not been concluded before the expiry of a period of at least 10 calendar days with effect from the day following the date of the publication of this notice.

5.

The Member States shall provide that paragraph 1(c) of this Article does not apply where:

the contracting authority considers that the award of a contract is in accordance with point (c) of Article 33(4) or with Article 34(6) of Directive 2014/24/EU,

the contracting authority has sent a contract award decision, together with a summary of reasons as referred to in the first indent of the fourth subparagraph of Article 2a(2) of this Directive, to the tenderers concerned, and,

the contract has not been concluded before the expiry of a period of at least 10 calendar days with effect from the day following the date on which the contract award decision is sent to the tenderers concerned if fax or electronic means are used or, if other means of communications are used, before the expiry of a period of either at least 15 calendar days with effect from the day following the date on which the contract award decision is sent to the tenderers concerned or at least 10 calendar days with effect from the day following the date of the receipt of the contract award decision.

The 10 that are cited most themselves, of 44.

  • Directive (EU) 2007/66Law

    … daher statt der Einführung einer obligatorischen Stillhaltefrist die Unwirksamkeit als wirksame Sanktion gemäß Artikel 2d der Richtlinie 89/665/EWG und Artikel 2d der Richtlinie 92/13/EWG für Verstöße gegen Artikel 32 Absatz 4 …

  • Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber), 11 September 2014. Ministero dell’Interno v Fastweb SpA.Decisioninterprets

    This request for a preliminary ruling concerns the interpretation of Article 2d(4) of Council Directive 89/665/EEC of 21 December 1989 on the coordination of the laws, regulations and administrative provisions relating to the application …

    11 Sep 2014 · 62013CJ0019

  • Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 26 November 2015. MedEval - Qualitäts-, Leistungs- und Struktur-Evaluierung im Gesundheitswesen GmbDecision

    With regard to the limitation periods for bringing actions, Article 2f(1) of Directive 89/665, inserted by Directive 2007/66, states that the Member States may provide for limitation periods for applications under Article 2d to have a …

    26 Nov 2015 · 62014CJ0166

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 17 June 2021. Simonsen & Weel A/S v Region Nordjylland og Region Syddanmark.Decisioninterprets

    Under the heading ‘Ineffectiveness’, Article 2d of Directive 89/665 provides, in paragraph 1 thereof: ‘Member States shall ensure that a contract is considered ineffective by a review body independent of the contracting authority or …

    17 Jun 2021 · 62020CJ0023

  • Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 7 September 2021. 'Klaipėdos regiono atliekų tvarkymo centras' v UAB.Decision

    In that regard, it follows from the fourth subparagraph of Article 1(1) of Directive 89/665 that the Member States are to take the measures necessary to ensure that, as regards inter alia contracts falling within the scope of Directive …

    7 Sep 2021 · 62019CJ0927

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 26 March 2020. HUNGEOD Közlekedésfejlesztési, Földmérési, Út- és Vasúttervezési Kft. and Others v Decision

    Article 2d of Directive 89/665, headed ‘Ineffectiveness’, was inserted by Directive 2007/66 and is worded as follows: ‘1. Member States shall ensure that a contract is considered ineffective by a review body independent of the …

    26 Mar 2020 · 62018CJ0496

  • Order of the Vice-President of the Court of 1 December 2021. Inivos Ltd and Inivos BV v European Commission.Decision

    Article 2d(1)(a) of Directive 89/665 reads as follows: ‘Member States shall ensure that a contract is considered ineffective by a review body independent of the contracting authority or that its ineffectiveness is the result of a …

    1 Dec 2021 · 62021CO0471

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 18 January 2024. CROSS Zlín, a.s. v Úřad pro ochranu hospodářské soutěže.Decision

    Article 2d of Directive 89/665, entitled ‘Ineffectiveness’, provides: ‘1. Member States shall ensure that a contract is considered ineffective by a review body independent of the contracting authority or that its ineffectiveness is …

    18 Jan 2024 · 62022CJ0303

  • Opinion of Advocate General Campos Sánchez-Bordona delivered on 7 September 2023. CROSS Zlín, a.s. v Úřad pro ochranu hospodářské soutěže.Decision

    Article 1 of Directive 89/665 requires Member States to take the legislative measures necessary to ensure that decisions taken by the contracting authorities may be reviewed effectively in accordance with the conditions set out in Articles …

    7 Sep 2023 · 62022CC0303

  • Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 7 August 2018. Hochtief AG v Budapest Főváros Önkormányzata.Decision

    It is appropriate to recall, first of all, that, under Articles 2d to 2f of Directive 89/665, the Member States may provide that, where damages are claimed on the ground that a decision was taken unlawfully, the contested decision must …

    7 Aug 2018 · 62017CJ0300