, Decision_act (EU) 1987/506

In force
–

another part was to enable the steel groups to discharge their responsibilities as parent companies to lossmaking subsidiaries. With this financing the subsidiaries had been able to undertake rationalization measures (especially in the wire-drawing sector); they had not used the funds to engage in unfair competition.

Moreover, some of the subsidiaries (engineering, construction) carried on business mainly outside the Community.

Three other Member States, two trade associations and one individual company also made representations to the Commission under the procedure.

III

The financial transfers under consideration here fall into two categories:

–

those intended to fund acquisitions by the steel groups of various businesses not in particular difficulty outside their mainstream ECSC steel business, so extending the range of their activities.

In its notice to the Member States on government provisions of capital to companies (5), the Commission reiterated the principle that the investment of public dividend capital in companies in circumstances where such investment would not be forthcoming from private investors operating under normal market conditions was state aid. It added that this was the case where the financial position of the company, and particularly the structure and volume of its debt, was such as to preclude a normal return on the investment within a reasonable period of time or where, because of inadequate cash-flow, the company would be unable to raise the funds required for an investment programme on the capital market.

In the present case, the steel groups which received government funding to acquire financially-sound Community businesses or to increase their stakes in such businesses were, at the time the funding was provided, in a financial position such that on the above criteria the funding must be considered aid,

–

those (the majority) intended to keep lossmaking Community subsidiaries of the steel groups in business by writing off their losses or increasing their capital or, in one case, to rescue an independent company in distress by taking it into one of the steel groups; in these cases the Community companies were the ultimate beneficiaries of the funds.

The funding of such businesses with a long record of losses (see section IV) must also be considered aid for the same reasons, even where the funding took the form of recapitalization of the companies.

IV