, Decision_act (EU) 1987/506

In force
–

Case No 6: Funding of various operations involving sums of less than FF 50 million by the steel groups either to acquire or increase their stakes in non-steel businesses or to cover the losses of such businesses, viz: special steels stockholding (FF 14 million); industrial fasteners (FF 3 million), railway wagons (FF 10 million); mechanical handling equipment (FF 15 million); pipes and tubes (FF 10 million); scrap-metal dealing (FF 30 million); machine tools (FF 18 million); primary processing (FF 36 million); sheet-metalworking and assembly (FF 20 million); engineering (FF 50 million); cold rolling (FF 35 million),

–

Case No 7: Funding of a construction company involved in construction projects in non-Community countries (Case No 7.1 - FF 1 499 million) and of an engineering company (Case No 7.2 - FF 106 million),

–

Case No 8: Funding of various forging and foundry businesses (FF 472 million),

–

Case No 9: Funding of operations in connection with the acquisition of a company producing stainless steel and nickel and cobalt alloy rolled products, wire and forgings (FF 210 million),

–

Case No 10: Funding of local industrial investment subsidiaries set up to attract new industry to steel areas (FF 574 million). This case will be dealt with in a separate decision.

All the above funding was provided without prior authorization by the Commission, in disregard of the French Government's obligations under Article 93 (3) of the EEC Treaty. The Commission therefore considered it to be illegal.

II

The French Government submitted its observations under the Article 93 (2) procedure by letters dated 24 April 1985 and 27 March 1986. It argued that, in providing funding in the form of new capital to the two state-owned steel groups to finance, directly or through subsidiaries, busi

nesses falling outside the ECSC steel sector, the state was merely fulfilling its responsibilities as shareholder. None of the funding had involved aid under Article 92 or was likely to affect the normal rules of competition within the Community. Indeed:

–

part of it was to pay for financial investment by the state-owned steel groups in existing businesses and thus involved an investment of risk capital,