Recital 4, Decision_act (EU) 1987/99

In force

The exception provided for in Article 92 (3) (c) is applicable to aid which facilitates the development of certain economic areas, but which does not adversely affect trading conditions to an extent contrary to the common interest.

The only circumstances in which the effect on trading conditions caused by regional aid can be regarded as not against the common interest for the purposes of Article 92 (3) (c) are where it can be shown that the aided region suffers from difficulties that, as well as being above average nationally, are also relatively severe by Community standards, that without the aid market forces would not eliminate these difficulties, that the level of the aid is in proportion to the difficulties, and that the grant of aid does not unduly distort competition within the common market in particular sectors.

To ensure that its Community-related assessment is systematic and objective, the Commission has developed a method of determining, for a given Member State, general threshold levels of structural unemployment and per capita gross domestic product from which regional aid can be deemed acceptable.

These thresholds are regularly reviewed in the light of the latest figures. The current thresholds from which regions in the Federal Republic are considered in principle to be eligible for aid are a level of per capita gross domestic product or gross value added at factor cost of less than 76 % of the national average or an average unemployment rate over five years of more than 145 % of the national average. The Federal Government was informed of these thresholds in a letter sent to the Federal Economics Minister dated 31 July 1985. The Federal Government noted the current thresholds in a memorandum to the Commission dated 22 January 1986. When the Commission opened the Article 93 (2) procedure in the present case, it took the figure of per capita gross value added at factor cost for the Labour market region Siegen, to which Betzdorf sub-district belongs, namely 95 % of the national average, as indicative of the situation in Betzdorf. The German Government did not challenge this. The average unemployment rate in Betzdorf sub-district over the period 1981 to 1985 was only 108 % of the national average.

On the basis of the thresholds, then, regional aid in Betzdorf employment office sub-district would not be compatible with the common market. The result obtained from applying the thresholds is taken only as a prima facie presumption, however, which may be revised in a second stage of the assessment procedure if other indicators of the present situation or future trends point to the opposite conclusion.