If the basic material is a stand, it shall satisfy the relevant requirements set out in Annex III. If the basic material is any of the following: a seed orchard, parents of a family, a clone or a clonal mixture, it shall satisfy the relevant requirements set out in Annex IV. The competent authority shall determine the selection criteria based on the purpose for which the FRM is intended to be used.
Tests set up for the approval of the basic material shall be prepared, laid out, conducted and the results thereof interpreted in accordance with internationally recognised procedures. For comparative tests, FRM shall be compared with one or preferably more approved or pre-chosen standards as referred to in point 3(b).
Tests shall be designed to assess the characteristics specified in point (ii) and those characteristics shall be indicated for each test in the test records.
Weight shall be given to characteristics considered important in view of the purpose for which the FRM is intended to be used. Those characteristics shall be evaluated in relation to the ecological conditions of the region in which the test is carried out, including current and projected climatic conditions.
The competent authorities or, where applicable, the professional operators shall keep records describing the following elements: the test sites, including the location, climate, soil, past use, establishment, management and any damage due to abiotic and biotic factors, together with all the results at the time of the evaluation. Where those records are kept by the professional operators, they shall be made available to the competent authorities.
Each sample of FRM shall be raised, planted and managed in an identical way as far as the types of plant material permit.
Each test shall be based on a statistically valid design in order that the individual characteristics of each component under examination can be evaluated.
The data from the tests shall be analysed using internationally recognised statistical methods and the results shall be presented for each characteristic examined.
The methodology used for the test and, if possible, the detailed results obtained shall be made freely accessible.
The competent authority of the Member State in which the test was carried out may designate a deployment area, and shall make information available through FOREMATIS about any characteristics of the FRM which might limit its usefulness.
If, during tests, it is proved that the FRM does not possess at least the characteristics of the basic material from which it was produced, then that FRM shall not be certified as ‘tested’.
The components of the following types of basic material may be genetically evaluated: seed orchards, parents of a family, clones and clonal mixtures.
Documentation
Additional documentation is required for approval of the basic material providing information about:
the identity, origin and pedigree of the evaluated components; and
the crossing design used to produce the FRM used in the evaluation tests.
Test procedures
The genetic value of each component shall be estimated using information from two or more evaluation test sites, at least one of which shall be in an environment relevant for the intended deployment area of the FRM.
The test period shall be of sufficient duration for the tested characteristics to be expressed.
The estimated superiority of the FRM to be marketed shall be calculated on the basis of the genetic values and the specific crossing design.
Evaluation tests and genetic calculations shall be approved by the competent authority.
Interpretation
The estimated superiority of the FRM shall be calculated against a reference population for a characteristic or set of characteristics. The reference population shall be defined in the breeding programme and described in the test reports.
The test reports shall state whether the estimated genetic value of the FRM is inferior to the reference population for any important characteristic.
The sample of the FRM for comparative testing shall be truly representative of the FRM derived from the basic material to be approved.
Sexually produced FRM for comparative testing shall be:
harvested in years of good flowering and good fruit/seed production, and
harvested by methods that ensure that the samples obtained are representative.
Artificial pollination may be used for the production of such FRM.
The performance of standards used for comparison in the tests shall, if possible, be known over a sufficiently long period in the region in which the test is to be carried out. The standards shall represent, in principle, basic material that has been shown to be useful for the relevant purpose at the time that the test starts, and in ecological conditions for which it is proposed to certify the FRM. The standards used for comparison in the tests shall be, as far as possible:
stands selected according to the criteria in Annex III, or
basic material officially approved for the production of FRM of the tested category.
For comparative testing of artificial hybrids, both parent tree species shall, if possible, be included among the standards.
Several standards shall be used whenever possible. When justified, standards may be replaced by the most suitable of the FRM under test or the mean of the components of the test.
The same standards shall be used in all tests over as wide a range of site conditions as possible.
A statistically significant superiority as compared with the standards shall be demonstrated for at least one important characteristic.
Any characteristics of economic or environmental importance which show significantly inferior results to the standards shall be reported, and their effects shall be compensated for by favourable characteristics.
Preliminary assessment of young trials may be the basis for provisional approval. Claims of superiority based on an early assessment shall be re-examined after 10 years at the latest.
Nursery, greenhouse and laboratory tests may be accepted by the competent authority for provisional approval or for final approval if it can be shown that there is a close correlation between the target characteristic and the characteristics normally assessed in forest stage tests. Other characteristics to be tested shall comply with the requirements set out in point 3.