9 1. PROCEDURE › 1.4. Subsequent procedure, Regulation (EU) 2025/2589

In forcesince 18 Dec 2025

In its comments to the provisional measures, CFNA submitted that the Commission had failed to adequately disclose its determination of the scope of the Union industry, did not disclose any key data regarding the Union industry’s production capacity, output, sales, exports, and consumption of different forms of choline chloride, and did not disclose the specific methodology used to calculate the dumping margin (only disclosing the profit margin and environmental and labour costs). It found and criticised that the disclosed information was limited to the final conclusions without revealing the underlying reasoning or calculation process and considered that this constitutes procedural defects of insufficient disclosure, rendering the review procedure substantially meaningless, excluding interested parties from information access, preventing them from examining and verifying the Commission’s preliminary determination, and from raising substantial challenges or counter-evidence, which seriously damaged the ability of interested parties including CFNA to reasonably exercise defense rights, and undermining procedural justice. After final disclosure, some of these comments were repeated.