With regard to Van Eeghen’s claim summarised in recital (31) above, the Commission noted that in Decision 2012/343/EU the request of the complainant to exclude simple soy protein concentrates of a kind used in animal feeding from the product scope had been accepted in view of inconsistent data concerning the EU industry, taking into account the clear technical, chemical and market-related differences between the two types of soy protein. The Commission considered the inconsistency of data as a relevant factor triggering the reduction of product scope in the Decision 2012/343/EU. In that case, following the limitation of the product scope, the sole company producing the product type excluded from the product scope was considered no longer part of the Union industry as it only produced the excluded product type. The Commission considered that the circumstances leading to the limitation of the product scope and the revision of the Union industry in that soy protein case do not apply in this proceeding, since Algry Quimica, a Union producer of choline chloride, produces both food and feed grade choline chloride and the complainants have indicated that they can and will produce it once that becomes economically viable. Therefore, the claim of Van Eeghen that the current product exclusion request should be accepted in view of the Commission’s course of action as summarised in Decision 2012/343/EU is rejected.
39 2. PRODUCT CONCERNED AND LIKE PRODUCT › 2.2. Claims regarding product scope › 2.2.1. Claims to exclude choline chloride destined for food applications › 2.2.1.2. Analysis of the comments by the Commission, Regulation (EU) 2025/2589
In forcesince 18 Dec 2025