As regards Hungary’s assertion that the more demanding and stricter requirements for the product specification of Hungarian ‘Tokaj/Tokaji’, when compared to the product specifications of Slovak ‘TOKAJSKÉ VÍNO zo slovenskej oblasti’, put Hungarian producers at a competitive disadvantage, the Commission takes the view that ‘Tokaj/Tokaji’ and ‘TOKAJSKÉ VÍNO zo slovenskej oblasti’ are distinct names and are related to distinct product specifications. For the purpose of the present application for registration, Slovakia is not required to comply with the Hungarian product specification of ‘Tokaj/Tokaji’. Equally, Hungary is not required to align its rules with the Slovak product specification of ‘Vinohradnícka oblasť Tokaj’ or of ‘TOKAJSKÉ VÍNO zo slovenskej oblasti’ and is free to set up and maintain its own requirements for ‘Tokaj/Tokaji’ wine. There is no requirement in Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013 that partially homonymous names are to share the same product specification. In the absence of any risk of confusion between the Slovak and the Hungarian PDOs, the possibly different standards do not affect the assessment under Article 100 of Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013. It is therefore groundless to raise an issue of competitive disadvantage as a result of stricter requirements of the product specification of a specific PDO compared to the product specification of another PDO. In conclusion, Hungary’s claim of a competitive disadvantage due to stricter production requirements should be rejected.
Recital 24, Regulation (EU) 2025/1291
In forcesince 2 Jul 2025