France did not agree with the conclusion of Finland that efficacy of the products of the biocidal product family has been proven for the intended use. France considered that, according to the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) Guidance on the Biocidal Products Regulation [ECHA Guidance on the Biocidal Products Regulation, Volume II, Efficacy – Assessment and Evaluation (Parts B+C), version 3.0 of April 2018 950efefa-f2bf-0b4a-a3fd-41c86daae468 (europa.eu)], both a phase 2 step 1 test and a simulated-use test are required. According to the data in the application, the phase 2 step 1 test, performed according to the EN 1276:2009 standard, did not meet the pass criteria, and the simulated-use test, which was a modified EN 1276:2009 test, cannot be considered, in the view of France, a simulated-use test, as it does not follow the recommendations in the guidance, which refers to a different test, namely the UBA method ‘Quantitative determination of the efficacy of drinking water disinfectants’ (‘UBA method’). Furthermore, France noted that the test organisms used in the second test were not those recommended in the guidance for a simulated-use test and the results did not meet the pass criteria of EN 1276:2009 or of the UBA method.
Recital 4, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2672
In forcesince 27 Nov 2023