Recital 13, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2672

In forcesince 27 Nov 2023

With regard to the modified EN 1276:2009 test designed by the applicant as simulated-use test, the Agency notes that only two of the four test organisms have achieved the required 5 lg reduction. Those two organisms, representing gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria, could be accepted as representative test organisms for the intended use. Regarding the modified test conditions, such as temperature, soiling and contact time, the Agency considers they reflect appropriately the intended use. Nonetheless, the volume tested (10 ml) is very small compared to the volume of water in reservoirs for animals, hence it does not reflect real-life conditions. Although the applicant had provided a test to demonstrate that hydrogen peroxide is readily miscible in water, the Agency considers it not representative and reliable for cases in which a small amount of hydrogen peroxide is added to a much bigger volume of water. Moreover, the Agency also considers that reliability of the modified test is doubtful, due to the lack of replicates. Replicates are important to enhance the reliability of test results, especially when test conditions are modified, and are clearly recommended in the EN 1276:2009 standard. The Agency notes that conducting at least three repetitions permits basic statistical analysis of the results thus enhancing the reliability of the test results, particularly for non-standardised tests.