46 2. DESCRIPTION OF THE 2019 LOAN AND PERTINENT FACTS › 2.2. Context in which the 2019 loan was granted to Alitalia › 2.2.2. The Commission decision on the 2017 loans, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2160

In forcesince 27 Mar 2023

In the sale scenario [Section 5.1.4.2.3.4 of Decision C(2021) 6659.], the Commission considered that at the maturity date (the end of the six-month period after disbursing the first loan) Alitalia SAI’s cash balance would have fallen far short of the amounts due on the loan and the interest and, thus, that the repayment would have depended on selling Alitalia SAI’s assets at a price amounting to at least EUR 627 million. Regarding the sale, the Commission argued that a market economy lender would have considered, in the first place, that it was unrealistic to expect Alitalia SAI’s assets to be sold within six months given that, according to studies, the average time such sales take for companies placed into extraordinary administration under Italian law is two to three years. In an ex ante assessment, based on the book value of the assets and the equity of AlitaliaSAI and on estimations of the discounted future cash flows of the company, in the Commission’s assessment a market economy lender would have valued the sales price of Alitalia SAI well below EUR 627 million. In an ex post assessment [Section 5.1.4.2.3.4.3.2 of Decision C(2021) 6659.] based on a study prepared for the extraordinary administration and the actual (non-binding) offers from other airline companies (Lufhansa, Easyjet) [Section 4.2.2.3 of Decision C(2021) 6659.], the Commission reached the same conclusion. Furthermore, the Commission’s independent assessment based on the ‘multiples method’, i.e. comparing Alitalia SAI’s financials to the parameters of similar companies [Section 5.1.4.2.3.4.3.3 of Decision C(2021) 6659.], confirmed the conclusion that a sale of Alitalia SAI’s assets would have brought an amount well below EUR 627 million, which would have been needed to repay the first loan [Recital 328 of Decision C(2021) 6659.].