Finally, the Commission stated that, under the case law of the Union courts, for a Member State to be considered acting as a private investor it must show that it carried out an assessment of the profitability of the measure prior to or at the same time as conferring economic advantage to an undertaking. While Italy provided various documents related to Alitalia SAI’s financial position prior to the granting of the loans, the Italian authorities were unable to provide evidence that they had carried out an ex ante assessment of the profitability, the likelihood of repayment of the loans or the appropriate pricing of the 2017 loans. On that basis, the Commission concluded that Italy did not act as a market operator, but as a public authority and that therefore the MEO test was inapplicable.
39 2. DESCRIPTION OF THE 2019 LOAN AND PERTINENT FACTS › 2.2. Context in which the 2019 loan was granted to Alitalia › 2.2.2. The Commission decision on the 2017 loans, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2160
In forcesince 27 Mar 2023