176 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.1. Existence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › 5.1.4. Advantage › 5.1.4.3. Application of the market economy operator test › Distortion of competition and impact on trade between Member States, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2160

In forcesince 27 Mar 2023

According to the extraordinary administration Commissioners, at the time of the measure Alitalia was the main Italian airline. In particular, in 2017 Alitalia had a market share of 12,6 % of the total passenger traffic from and to Italy and during the first 10 months of 2017 carried about 18,5 million passengers (16,3 million by Alitalia SAI and 2,2 million by Cityliner), of which 55 % on domestic routes, 32 % on international routes and 13 % on intercontinental routes. The extraordinary administration commissioner’s trimestral report for the period January–March 2021, published on 22 March 2022 [Relazione Trimestrale ex art. 61, 2° comma, D. Lgs. N. 270/1999 della procedura di amministrazione straordinaria relativa alle società Alitalia SAI S.p.A. in Amministrazione Straordinaria Alitalia CityLiner S.p.A. in Amministrazione Straordinaria, published on 22.3.2022, p. 16, https://cdn.fallcoweb.it/sito_procedura/pdf/alitalia/rel_31032021.pdf.], described the Italian air passenger transport market as highly competitive and characterised by, inter alia, a high penetration of low-cost carriers on the domestic market (the highest in Europe) and on the intra-European market. In 2019, Alitalia’s market shares decreased to 37 % of total passengers on domestic flights, where low-cost carriers held an aggregated market share of 57 % (Ryanair 35 %, Easyjet 11 % and Volotea 8 %), and accounted for approximately 7 % of the total passenger traffic in medium–long haul flights [ENAC and Eurocontrol data, https://www.enac.gov.it/pubblicazioni/dati-di-traffico-2019.]. In 2020, Alitalia’s market share on domestic flights again decreased (around 35 % of the total passengers, equal to Ryanair’s market share), while, in terms of traffic from and to Italy, Alitalia represented around 7,7 % of the total passengers [ENAC data, https://www.enac.gov.it/news/dati-di-traffico-2020. The EA Commissioners reported that Alitalia nevertheless increased its passenger market share in the flights to/from Italy from 15,9 % of Q1 2020 to 28,5 % of Q1 2021, due also to the increase in the number of seats offered (+ 3,1 %), https://cdn.fallcoweb.it/sito_procedura/pdf/alitalia/rel_31032021.pdf.] and Ryanair was the first carrier, with a 28 % market share; other eight carriers flanked Ryanair and Alitalia, with market shares between 1 % and 2 %, for a total of 10,2 %; finally, another 228 operators, with a share of less than 1 % each, represented the remaining 21,9 % of the traffic from and to Italy [ENAC data, https://temi.camera.it/leg18/post/OCD15_14420/enac-i-dati-traffico-aereo-2020.html.].