171 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.1. Existence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › 5.1.4. Advantage › 5.1.4.3. Application of the market economy operator test, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2160

In forcesince 27 Mar 2023

Therefore, the Commission takes into consideration what the financial situation of Alitalia would have been in the lack of the 2017 loans of a total of EUR 900 million. In that scenario, Alitalia would have had a negative cash position of EUR 590 million on 30 September 2019 [The negative EUR 590 million cash position is the result of subtracting the EUR 900 million of the 2017 loans from the total available cash on 30 September 2019, i.e. EUR 310 million.]. Presumably, Alitalia’s cash position would have been even worse on 26 October 2019, as the company was loss-making [Alitalia made a net negative EUR 49 milllion EBITA for the period 1Q 2018 till 3Q 2019.]. Since a company can operate only if cash inflows are greater than the outflows so that it has a positive and sufficient cash balance, the Commission considers that the bankruptcy of Alitalia is a reasonable scenario without the initial loan.