In addition, given that there is no evidence in the case file that the 2019 loan was repaid, it can be inferred that the maturity date of the 2019 loan was postponed or the debt was, de jure or de facto, cancelled. Given Alitalia’s persistent financial difficulties after October 2017 and absent any proof to the contrary, it appears that the State as a lender never received remuneration for either its liquidity cost or the credit risk related to Alitalia. Moreover, Italy did not submit any ex ante study showing that the State had a financial interest to grant the 2019 loan or to prolong the repayment. That behaviour, namely granting the 2019 loan without a specific ex ante study of profitability of the loan and absent any evidence that Italy tried to recover the loan, is not in line with that of a MEO but demonstrates the interest of a public authority to maintain the continuity of transport service provided by Alitalia, as plainly reiterated by the Italian authorities [See, inter alia, the Parliament’s debate regarding the conversion of the Government’s Decree n. 137/2019 into Law, https://www.camera.it/leg18/126?tab=6&leg=18&idDocumento=2284&sede=&tipo=.].
152 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.1. Existence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › 5.1.4. Advantage › 5.1.4.2. Applicability of the market economy operator test › 5.1.4.2.1. Italy acted as public authority and not as a market economy operator › 5.1.4.2.1.3. The objective pursued, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2160
In forcesince 27 Mar 2023
- celex=32019R0137