2. RESULTS OF THE INVESTIGATION › 2.6. Value of parts and added value, Regulation (EU) 2022/301

In forcesince 24 Feb 2022
(86)

The Commission rejected the use of either of the three alternatives that the PGTEX Group proposed in view of a number of inconsistencies the Commission found, in Annex 7.2 of the letter of 12 October 2021, with regard to the proposed alternatives:

The month of March 2020 was not mentioned by PGTEX Morocco SARL as a month of production in Annex 7.2 of the letter of 12 October 2021. PGTEX Morocco SARL stated for the first time [In response to Question C.4.1 of PGTEX Morocco SARL’s completed questionnaire, PGTEX Morocco SARL stated that the production started from April 2020. This statement was re-confirmed as a reply to question 1 on page 1 of its deficiency reply.] on 12 October 2021 that there had been production in March 2020, but that this production in March 2020 was only booked in its production data for the month of April 2020. This means that the Commission could not exclude other errors and/or delays in booking the monthly production. Therefore, the method as proposed by the PGTEX Group to monthly allocate which GFF machines were operational and which were not, could not be used as a basis;

Using the cost data of December 2020 only could not be accepted either as the capacity utilisation rate for the month of December 2020 was not representative for the capacity utilisation rate for the full year 2020;

Using the cost data for the period July – December 2020 could not be accepted either for the same reason as mentioned under the second proposed alternative. The capacity utilisation rate for the period July – December 2020 was not representative for the capacity utilisation rate for the full year 2020.

Therefore, the Commission concluded that the capacity utilisation rate over the full year of 2020 was the most appropriate indicator to reduce the fully booked depreciation rate in a reasonable way in the framework of the value-added calculation.