Concerning the rental cost, PGTEX Morocco did not provide its rental contracts in its reply in the exemption claim form, despite the important rental costs it incurred in 2020 [The Commission requested in the exemption claim form that any cooperating producer should provide all main contracts, both from related and unrelated parties,]. In its exemption claim form, it informed the Commission that it had installed all its GFF-machines at one location (plant – phase 1). It initially stated that it only rented this one plant as it stated that it “only has one production site”, despite the question in the exemption claim form to provide the addresses of all its production sites. Subsequently, PGTEX Morocco SARL, however, provided two rental contracts as a reply to the deficiency letter of the Commission, indicating that PGTEX Morocco SARL rented two separate premises from two different property owners during the reporting period. Since PGTEX Morocco SARL had claimed previously in its exemption claim form that the GFF-machines, which were operational during 2020, were only installed in one of these two rented plants, the rental amounts incurred in 2020 for the second plant (plant – phase 2) should have been excluded from the rental cost and value added cost. In addition, because of the low capacity utilisation, the Commission, in its value added cost calculation, could also not accept the total rental cost for the plant – phase 1 as it was not fully used due to the fact that the GFF-machines were not producing in the first quarter of 2020 and not running at full capacity during the other quarters of 2020. The total rental cost as reported was not accepted by the Commission because of the above reasons.
91 2. RESULTS OF THE INVESTIGATION › 2.6. Value of parts and added value, Regulation (EU) 2022/301
In forcesince 24 Feb 2022cited 1×
Judgment of the General Court (Tenth Chamber, Extended Composition) of 4 December 2024. PGTEX Morocco v European Commission.Decision
As regards the rental cost, in recital 91 of the contested implementing regulation, the Commission stated the following: ‘[The applicant] did not provide its rental contracts in its reply in the exemption claim form, despite the …
4 Dec 2024 · 62022TJ0246